To Date: 04-10-2012
Hon’ble Minister of Railways,
Rail Mantralaya, Railway Board,
Rail Bhavan, New Delhi-110001.
Honored Sir,
Sub: Representation from-V.Seshadri, Asst. Security Commissioner, RPF, Retiredsenior’s
names dropped from the Inspectors/ASCs’ ad hoc list and juniors given
promotion as Commandants/DSCs in RPF- pray justice and to remove disparity and
anomaly-reg.
Ref:1) DoPPW/P/2012/00214 dated 16-01-2012; 2)- DoP&PW on line regn. No.
DOPPW/E/2012/01390 Dated 25-8-2012 3)- MOR No. Registration
Number: MORLY/E/2012/03392 dated 31-5-2012 & 4) Hon’ble President of India’s
Secretariat No. PRESEC/E/2011/10472 sent to Hon’ble MOR vide No.P1/D/1407110087
dated 14-7-2011.
<><><><><>
This is in continuation to my earlier representations/letters/on line submissions
lodged earlier (Details/list enclosed- no replies/even ack. received so far from Railway
Board or from DG/RPF/NDRB, New Delhi) for assigning my correct position in the
seniority list published on 19-4-2012 and for finalizing the names of ASCs for
regularization and promotion to the rank of DSC as per list of 04-8-2006, etc. But, the
Railway Board or the DG, RPF have not taken any action on my grievance so far. I have
also lodged representation under Rule102 of the RPF Rules.
On 04-8-2006 Railway Board published seniority list for regular promotion to
the post of ASCs. Without finalizing the names of Inspectors of 1983/Grade-I of 1991 batch,
and by suppressing the above list, they have made out another list on 19-4-2012 duly
dropping the names of the retired persons and promoted juniors in place of seniors on the
plea that the seniors have since been retired on the date/year when the DPCs were held.
My name stands at serial number 101 in the List, while the names of my juniors like, S/Sri.
K.Laxma Nayak (Sr.No.113), K.V.Babu (143), K.J.Joy (170), and a score of others have been
promoted to the rank of DSC duly sidelining the senior’s names like me.
As per DoP&T.O.M.No.22011/4/98-ESTT. (D), Dated 12-10-1998, the DPCs , held
in later years have to include the names of the retired employees also in the panel lists
against the year wise vacancies even by preparing extended panels. But, ironically, it was
misinterpreted otherwise and our names dropped from the panel lists on the ground that
we retired on the date/year of DPC when panel lists prepared and juniors given promotions
in our place by the DPCs, Railway Board and the DG, RPF whereby our names have been
dropped from the panel lists for the vacancy position on the years when the regularization
and promotions were made effective.
In the RPF department the DPCs were not held every year in time schedule on
Administrative delays, due to which the RPF pensioners are losing benefit of notional
promotion and pensionary benefits for which they are eligible from the rank of ASCs to
DSCs in RPF.
By this ANOMALY, THE JUNIORS in the RPF are given the benefit of higher
Scales of Pay and Grade Pay, and also the Pensionary benefits and the SENIORS ARE
DENIED OF EQUAL PAY / PENSION even in EQUAL RANK.
The Honorable Supreme Courts’ Judgment Order dated 02-5-2011, in SLP-Appeal
(Civil) in W P No.14263 of 2004 in the Honorable High Court of Delhi envisaged – to effect
promotion from the date of eligibility and to extend this facility to all who are in similarly
placed situation and to give similar treatment, even though they are not the Petitioners.
The same principle may kindly be applied herein also in my case. The Hon’ble
High Court of Madras, while dismissing the Writ Appeal No.538/2012 in W.P. No.16572 of
1998 filed by the Union of India, Railway Board, DG/RPF and others in its Judgment Order
dated 12-6-2012 upheld the judgment delivered in WP No.16572/1998 …….. Directing the
Appellants to consider the Seniority list within the fixed time… Relief must be given to all
the Petitioners since at the time of filing of WP; they were very much in service…..
In the light of this Judgment order, the RPF pensioners – Inspectors/ASCs Adhoc
who were not the Petitioners in the above W.P. have submitted their representations to the
Railway Board, DG/RPF with a request to consider such pensioners also on par with the
case of the retired pensioners/petitioners and grant retirement benefits to them.
Under the circumstances, I humbly pray your Honor for kind intervention on the
matter and do justice to the senior citizens and RPF pensioners for which act of kindness
we shall ever be grateful.
Yours faithfully,
(V.SESHADRI)
ASC/RPF/RETD
Address:
V.Seshsdri, ASC/RPF/Retd,
President, RPF Pensioner’s Welfare Assn.,
South Central Railway,HQs.Sec’bad,
H.No.24-147/4/2,
East Anandbagh,
Malkajgiri,
SECUNDERABAD-500047.
To Date: 04-10-2012
Hon’ble Executive Director,
(Finance, Estt.), Ministry of Railways,
Rail Mantralaya, Railway Board,
Room No.532,
Rail Bhavan,
New Delhi-110001.
Honored Sir,
Sub: Representation from-V.Seshadri, Asst. Security Commissioner, RPF, Retiredsenior’s
names dropped from the Inspectors/ASCs’ ad hoc list and juniors given
promotion as Commandants/DSCs in RPF- pray justice and to remove disparity and
anomaly-reg.
Ref: 1)DoPPW/P/2012/00214 dated 16-01-2012;2)-DoP&PW on line regn. No.
DOPPW/E/2012/01390 Dated 25-8-2012 3)-MOR No. Registration
Number: MORLY/E/2012/03392 dated 31-5-2012 & 4) Hon’ble President of India’s
Secretariat No. PRESEC/E/2011/10472 sent to Hon’ble MOR vide No.P1/D/1407110087
dated 14-7-2011.
<><><><><>
This is in continuation to my earlier representations/letters/on line submissions
lodged earlier (Details/list enclosed- no replies/even ack. received so far from Railway
Board or from DG/RPF/NDRB, New Delhi) for assigning my correct position in the
seniority list published on 19-4-2012 and for finalizing the names of ASCs for
regularization and promotion to the rank of DSC as per list of 04-8-2006, etc. But, the
Railway Board or the DG, RPF have not taken any action on my grievance so far. I have
also lodged representation under Rule102 of the RPF Rules.
On 04-8-2006 Railway Board published seniority list for regular promotion to
the post of ASCs. Without finalizing the names of Inspectors of 1983/Grade-I of 1991 batch,
and by suppressing the above list, they have made out another list on 19-4-2012 duly
dropping the names of the retired persons and promoted juniors in place of seniors on the
plea that the seniors have since been retired on the date/year when the DPCs were held.
My name stands at serial number 101 in the List, while the names of my juniors like, S/Sri.
K.Laxma Nayak (Sr.No.113), K.V.Babu (143), K.J.Joy (170), and a score of others have been
promoted to the rank of DSC duly sidelining the senior’s names like me.
As per DoP&T.O.M.No.22011/4/98-ESTT. (D), Dated 12-10-1998, the DPCs , held
in later years have to include the names of the retired employees also in the panel lists
against the year wise vacancies even by preparing extended panels. But, ironically, it was
misinterpreted otherwise and our names dropped from the panel lists on the ground that
we retired on the date/year of DPC when panel lists prepared and juniors given promotions
in our place by the DPCs, Railway Board and the DG, RPF whereby our names have been
dropped from the panel lists for the vacancy position on the years when the regularization
and promotions were made effective.
In the RPF department the DPCs were not held every year in time schedule on
Administrative delays, due to which the RPF pensioners are losing benefit of notional
promotion and pensionary benefits for which they are eligible from the rank of ASCs to
DSCs in RPF.
By this ANOMALY, THE JUNIORS in the RPF are given the benefit of higher
Scales of Pay and Grade Pay, and also the Pensionary benefits and the SENIORS ARE
DENIED OF EQUAL PAY / PENSION even in EQUAL RANK.
The Honorable Supreme Courts’ Judgment Order dated 02-5-2011, in SLP-Appeal
(Civil) in W P No.14263 of 2004 in the Honorable High Court of Delhi envisaged – to effect
promotion from the date of eligibility and to extend this facility to all who are in similarly
placed situation and to give similar treatment, even though they are not the Petitioners.
The same principle may kindly be applied herein also in my case. The Hon’ble
High Court of Madras, while dismissing the Writ Appeal No.538/2012 in W.P. No.16572 of
1998 filed by the Union of India, Railway Board, DG/RPF and others in its Judgment Order
dated 12-6-2012 upheld the judgment delivered in WP No.16572/1998 …….. Directing the
Appellants to consider the Seniority list within the fixed time… Relief must be given to all
the Petitioners since at the time of filing of WP; they were very much in service…..
In the light of this Judgment order, the RPF pensioners – Inspectors/ASCs Adhoc
who were not the Petitioners in the above W.P. have submitted their representations to the
Railway Board, DG/RPF with a request to consider such pensioners also on par with the
case of the retired pensioners/petitioners and grant retirement benefits to them.
Under the circumstances, I humbly pray your Honor for kind intervention on the
matter and do justice to the senior citizens and RPF pensioners for which act of kindness
we shall ever be grateful.
Yours faithfully,
(V.SESHADRI)
ASC/RPF/RETD
Address:
V.Seshsdri, ASC/RPF/Retd,
President, RPF Pensioner’s Welfare Assn.,
South Central Railway,HQs.Sec’bad,
H.No.24-147/4/2,
East Anandbagh,
Malkajgiri,
SECUNDERABAD-500047.
Copy submitted to:
Hon’ble President of India, President’s Secretariat, (Public-I, Section),
Rashtrapati Bhavan, New Delhi-110004 for favour kind infn., in ref. to
Ltr.No.P1/D/1407110087 dated 14-7-2011, addressed to Ministry of Railways,
and to others; No reply received so far on my petition dated 30-6- 2011, and
others. Kindly do the needful.
Hon’ble Minister of Railways, Rail Mantralaya, Railway Board, Rail Bhavan,
New Delhi;
The Director, Dept. of Pension & Pensioner’s Welfare, Ministry of Personnel,
Public Grievances and Pensions, Govt. of India, Lok Nayak Bhavan, Khan
Market, New Delhi-110003;
The President, AIRPF Retired Officers Welfare Association, C/O Sri.S.C.
Kapoor, DSC/RPF/Retd, #154/4, Urban Estate, GURGAON-122001;
The Pension Grievance Officer (PGO), CPEMGRAMS, National e-Governance
Plan (NeGP), Dept. of Welfare, Ministry of Personnel, Public grievances and
Pensions, Govt. of India, New Delhi;
Sri.Y.N.Sastry, President, All India Retired Railwaymen’s Federation,
Chikalguda, Secunderabad;
Dy. Comptroller and Auditor General of India (Railways), Room No.224,
Railway Board, Rail Bhavan, New Delhi-110001;
Executive Director (Pension Grievances), Ministry of Railways, Railway
Board, Room No.471, Rail Bhavan, New Delhi-110001;in ref. to Under
Secretary, GOI, Ministry of P,PG&P,D/o P&P Welfare, Third Floor, Lok Nayak
Bhavan, Khan Market, New Delhi-110003 Ltr. No.. No.DOPPW/P/2012/00214
dated 16-01-2012;
Sri. T.K.A.Nair, Advisor to the Hon’ble PM of India, Cabinet Secretariat, South
Block, PMO’s Office, Raisine Hill, New Delhi-110011;
Sri. Sam Pitroda, Advisor to the Hon’ble PM of India, Cabinet Secretariat,
South Block, PMO’s Office, Raisine Hill, New Delhi-110011, in continuation to
my emails sent earlier;
The Executive Director,( Finance, Estt.),Room No.532, Ministry of Railways,
Railway Board, Room No.471, Rail Bhavan, New Delhi-110001;in ref. to our
meeting held on 28-9-2006 in your Chamber along with our President,
Sri.Y.N.Sastry,of AIRRF please. Kindly do the needful.
For favor of kind information and further necessary action please.
Yours faithfully,
(V.SESHADRI)
ASC/RPF/RETD
ADDRESS:
V.Seshsdri, ASC/RPF/Retd,
President, RPF Pensioner’s Welfare Assn.,
South Central Railway,HQs.Sec’bad,
H.No.24-147/4/2,
East Anandbagh,
Malkajgiri,
SECUNDERABAD-500047.